15
Saturday
December 2018
10:21 AM IST
News Headlines
Trump's son-in-law Jared Kushner possible next chief of staff: US media        Sri Lanka PM Mahinda Rajapaksa to resign, says his son after court setback        Rahul Gandhi After Rafale Verdict: "Will Prove PM Helped Anil Ambani"        Author Amitav Ghosh Honoured With 54th Jnanpith Award        Supreme Court sees no wrongdoing in Rafale deal, rules out probe        India bowled a little bit short, Australia pacers could benefit: Border        ISL: FC Goa thrash NorthEast United 5-1        BWF World Tour Finals: PV Sindhu, Sameer Verma Register Easy Wins To Enter Semifinals        Diving legend says HIV-contracted friend inspired him to Olympic gold        India beat Pakistan to reach final of Emerging Teams Asia Cup        Boosting exports key to make India $5-tn economy by 2025: Kant        Prabhu, US Commerce Secretary to discuss trade issues on Feb 14        Ceasefire for key Yemen port agreed at peace talks: UN        Britain's May sees no 'immediate breakthrough' at EU        Poll results prove Ram Temple or communal polarisation doesn't cut ice with people: Sinha        Ashok Gehlot appeals to Cong workers in Raj to maintain peace        Rahul tweets pic with Kamal Nath, Scindia as race for CM moves to Bhopal        Aussies will fight back, but India has upper hand: Ghavri        World Tour Finals: Tough road ahead for Sindhu; Sameer too eyes knockout berth        Govt should consider 100% FDI in multi-brand retail trade: CII report        
Home   | Main News   | Kerala  | National   | International  | Business   | Sports   | Entertainment   | Columns   | Offbeat   | Health   | About Deepika 
Main News
Supreme Court sees no wrongdoing in Rafale deal, rules out probe
 
(New Delhi, Dec 14, 2018):Vindicating the position of the central government and Prime Minister Narendra Modi, the Supreme Court on Friday said there was “no occasion to really doubt” the procurement process of 36 Rafale fighter jets “even if minor deviations have occurred”.

The Congress had accused Modi of malfeasance in the deal. The three-judge Bench led by Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi said after perusing the material provided by the government and having interacted with Air Force officers, the court did not see any reason as to why it should intervene in “the sensitive issue of the purchase of 36 defence aircraft by the Indian government”.

The Bench said the court lacked the technical expertise to examine issues such as pricing and the choice of offset partners. Justice Gogoi cited national security concerns to say it could not step into issues such as defence contracts and procurements.

“Perceptions of individuals cannot be the basis for a fishing and roving enquiry by this court, especially in such matters. We, thus, dismiss all the writ petitions,” the Bench said.

Apart from advocate M L Sharma, who had moved the first plea in the case, former BJP ministers Yashwant Sinha and Arun Shourie, and senior advocate Prashant Bhushan had filed separate pleas, in which they had petitioned the court to order a court-monitored probe into the decision-making process of the government while buying the jets, the alleged difference in prices in the new deal as compared to the old deal signed by the United Progressive Alliance government, and the choice of the Indian offset partner.

On October 10, the court had asked the government to place before it the details of the steps taken while arriving at the decision to buy the 36 fighter jets. It had made clear that the details being sought were only to ensure the correctness of the decision-making process.

The court had said it would not go into the issue of pricing or matters related to the technical stability of the fighter jets.

The apex court on Friday reiterated its earlier stand and said it could not sit in judgment of the wisdom of deciding to purchase 36 aircraft in place of 126.

“We cannot possibly compel the government to go in for purchasing 126 aircraft,” the court said.

The three judges steered clear of the issue of escalation in the cost of the fighter jets and said though they were inclined to go into the details of pricing, it was not the job of the court to carry out a comparison of pricing details.

The court accepted the government’s claim that there was a commercial advantage in the purchase of 36 Rafale aircraft as compared to 126 owing to better terms of maintenance and weaponry.

It did not venture into the issue of choosing an offset partner for the deal, which has been perhaps the biggest sparring issue for the government and the opposition, either, and said it did not find substantial material to show that the government showed commercial favours to any party.

Though Reliance Aerostructure was formed recently, the court did not go into the details of commercial agreements between the Anil Ambani-led Anil Dhirbubhai Ambani Group and Dassault, and said it was “neither appropriate nor within the experience of this court to step into this arena of what is technically feasible or not”.


Rahul tweets pic with Kamal Nath, Scindia as race for CM moves to Bhopal
Cong leads in R'than, Chhattisgarh and MP; TRS races ahead in Telangana, MNF in Mizoram
RLSP chief Upendra Kushwaha resigns from Union council of ministers
'Won't hesitate from another surgical strike if need arises'
Modi used surgical strikes for 'political capital': Rahul
Rajasthan records 74 per cent turnout
Cal HC says can't give permission for BJP rally at this stage, after WB govt refuses to allow event
Christian Michel sent to 5-day CBI custody by court in VVIP chopper case
Sabarimala: Kerala Moves SC Seeking Transfer of Cases From HC
Election Body Admits Cameras Failed For Over An Hour At EVM Strongroom
K Krishnankutty sworn in as Kerala Water Resources Minister
CPM Leader PK Sasi Suspended From Party Over Harassment Charge
‘People will correct Kerala govt’: Union minister Pon Radhakrishnan on Sabarimala row
Fresh protest in Sabarimala
Sabarimala board to move SC, buy time to implement order
Sabarimala board to move SC, buy time to implement order
Top India, China officials hold defence, security dialogue, agree to step up military exchanges
Flipkart Group CEO Binny Bansal quits over 'serious personal misconduct' charges
70 per cent turnout in first phase of Chhattisgarh polls: EC
PM celebrates Diwali with soldiers in Harshil near India-China border
KERALA NEWS
Activist Rehana Fathima, Who Attempted Sabarimala Trek, Arrested Over Facebook Post
 (Kochi, Nov 28, 2018): Model and activist Rehana Fathima, who tried to reach Kerala's Sabarim  
Good news for Keralite Nurses: IELTS cut-off reduced to 6.5
BJP leader K Surendran, 71 others granted bail
Sabarimala protests: Arrests up to 2061, Kerala HC warns police
INTERNATIONAL NEWS
Trump's son-in-law Jared Kushner possible next chief of staff: US media
 (Washington, Dec 14, 2018):Donald Trump's son-in-law and senior adviser Jared Kushner is on t
Sri Lanka PM Mahinda Rajapaksa to resign, says his son after court setback
Ceasefire for key Yemen port agreed at peace talks: UN
Britain's May sees no 'immediate breakthrough' at EU
NATIONAL NEWS
Rahul Gandhi After Rafale Verdict: "Will Prove PM Helped Anil Ambani"
 (New Delhi, Dec 14, 2018):Hours after the Supreme Court's clean chit to the government on the
Author Amitav Ghosh Honoured With 54th Jnanpith Award
Poll results prove Ram Temple or communal polarisation doesn't cut ice with people: Sinha
Ashok Gehlot appeals to Cong workers in Raj to maintain peace
Untitled Page
Rashtra Deepika LTD
Copyright @ 2018 , Rashtra Deepika Ltd.